Stressed woman at a desk behind a tall stack of tabbed paperwork, with the caption 'Regulation is overhead. Price it in.'

Regulation Is Squeezing Small Firms: How to Protect Your Margin

ICAEW has asked nearly 700 small firms and sole practitioners what is holding back their growth, and the answer isn’t AI or competition. As ICAEW’s director of practice Sarah Ghaffari wrote on AccountingWEB on 9 November, the growing volume and complexity of regulation, along with government policy, are the biggest constraints for firms of every size. For many owners, regulation is also feeding the decision to leave.

The bigger picture: regulation is now a profit issue

The research, Sole Practitioners and Small Firms in Focus, extends three years of ICAEW work on mid-tier firms to practices with between two and 10 principals and to sole practitioners. Ghaffari describes the overall picture as one of stability, pragmatism and adaptability rather than disruption. That’s reassuring, but the detail is more pointed.

Both small firms and sole practitioners named the same three macro trends affecting the profession: regulatory and compliance change, the impact of generative AI, and UK economic and public policy. Both expect to use more AI and automation. And when asked about the future, more than half of sole practitioners said they were considering or pursuing a route to exit, compared with about a third of small firms. Retirement is part of that, but Ghaffari notes that the volume and complexity of regulation also plays a significant part.

There’s an important counterweight. Respondents expect demand for accountants to keep growing, with more emphasis on judgment, systems thinking and ethical oversight. Small firms and sole practitioners are still winning new clients who contribute to fee growth, and tax advice and financial planning are the most common advisory services they offer.

So the market isn’t shrinking. What’s shrinking is the margin left after compliance, and that is what pushes owners towards the door.

What independent accountants need to know

Regulation is overhead, and overhead must be priced. Every new rule, from AML supervision to MTD and identity verification, adds hours that most accounting firms absorb rather than bill. When those hours aren’t recovered, a practice can grow its fee income and still feel poorer each year.

Private equity isn’t the only way out. According to the research, one fifth of respondents see private equity investment as a future option, but only 5% believe such investment benefits the profession. Many owners clearly feel uneasy about it. Selling to PE should be a choice, not the default because compliance has become unmanageable.

AI skills are emerging as a gap. Some members flagged AI skills as a significant future gap. Firms that use AI to take friction out of compliance, such as data capture, document handling and client chasing, will have more capacity for the advisory work clients value.

Mixed outlook means uneven outcomes. Small firms are generally more optimistic than sole practitioners. The practices that thrive will be the ones that treat regulation as a design problem to solve, not just a burden to endure.

What forward-thinking practices are already doing

The firms protecting their margin have stopped treating compliance as something that just happens to them. They tend to do five things.

They measure compliance time. They track how many hours AML checks, onboarding, MTD quarterly updates and regulatory admin actually take, per client and per service. Most firms that do this for a month find a meaningful gap between the time spent and what they bill.

They write the cost into their engagement letters and fees. Once the time is visible, it can be priced. That might mean a separate onboarding fee, a compliance element within a fixed fee or a minimum fee per engagement. Clients rarely object when the reason is explained clearly.

They standardise relentlessly. One onboarding process, one set of AML templates, one software stack wherever possible. Variety is expensive when every variation needs its own compliance check.

They prune the client list. Low-fee, high-friction clients absorb a disproportionate share of compliance time. Removing or repricing them frees capacity for clients who value advice.

They grow advisory alongside compliance. ICAEW’s findings show tax advice and financial planning are already the most common advisory services. Firms that build these into structured, priced offers rather than giving them away in passing improve their margin with clients they already have.

How this connects to growth

Margin and growth are linked. A practice that has priced its compliance properly can afford to invest in winning better clients, and better clients improve margin further. A practice that hasn’t is stuck chasing volume to stand still.

That’s why marketing for accountants should focus on the clients you want, not just more clients. If tax advice and financial planning are where your margin lies, your website, your local SEO and your Google My Business for accountants profile should say so plainly, with dedicated service pages, local case studies and reviews that mention advisory outcomes. The same clear, specific content is what AI assistants look for when someone asks who can help with succession planning or inheritance tax in their area, which is why AI SEO matters here too.

There’s another growth opportunity in the research. If more than half of sole practitioners are thinking about exit, many client books will change hands in the next few years. Firms with healthy margins, efficient compliance and a visible local brand will be the natural buyers or successors. For regional accounting practices looking to grow, that could be the most efficient source of new clients available.

Regulation shouldn’t decide when you leave

ICAEW’s research shows a profession that is steady, adaptable and still finding new clients. But it also shows owners whose plans are increasingly shaped by regulation rather than by their own ambitions. That shouldn’t be acceptable. Regulation will keep growing, and practices can’t control that. They can control whether it is priced, systemised and shared out sensibly, or simply absorbed until the business isn’t worth running.

Doing this alone is hard, especially for smaller practices without a dedicated operations or marketing function. That’s why many independent firms are pooling resources. The CharterGroup Alliance gives accounting practices shared compliance and training support, marketing that brings in the right clients, and a network of peers dealing with the same pressures. If you’d rather grow your firm than be squeezed out of it, find out how to join the CharterGroup Alliance.

Published by the CharterGroup team